'Operation Mincemeat at Mayflower Theatre is completely irresistible'

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

When a show arrives with a reputation like Operation Mincemeat, expectations are inevitably going to be high. 

After picking up two Olivier Awards in the West End, the production crossed the Atlantic and added a Tony Award to its accolades. Now, it has arrived at Mayflower Theatre, where it runs until Saturday, November 21, and trust me, you don’t want to miss it.

I've been waiting to see Operation Mincemeat for years, so it’s safe to say I went in expecting a lot. Somehow, it delivered even more. 

Inventive, creative and genuinely hilarious, Operation Mincemeat is one of those rare shows where you find yourself wondering how anyone came up with it in the first place. 

The musical takes us back to 1943 and one of the strangest operations of the Second World War: Britain’s plan to use a dead body, dressed as a Royal Marines officer and carrying fake documents, to convince Germany that the Allies intended to invade Greece rather than Sicily. 

It's not exactly obviously comedy – or musical – material. But it works.  

Brilliant - Holly Sumpton as Ewen Montagu (Image: Matt Crockett)

With just five actors taking on a seemingly endless number of characters, role-swapping is inevitable, but the speed and ease with which they did it was incredible to watch. Characters changed within the blink of an eye.

By the end of the first act, the company were effortlessly jumping between confident MI5 “rich boys” and hard-working naval personnel beneath the waves, entrusted with their precious cargo. I almost forgot I was watching the same five people.

Holly Sumpton was sublime as the arrogant Ewen Montagu. Armed with some of the funniest lines in the show, Sumpton commanded the stage and made the larger-than-life character endlessly entertaining. 

But some of the musical’s best moments come when it suddenly slows everything down. 

A scene from Operation MincemeatChristian Andrews as Hester Leggatt (Image: Matt Crockett)

Christian Andrews was incredible as the strict administrative assistant Hester Leggatt. “Dear Bill” has real heart and comes close to being heartbreaking.

That contrast is what makes Operation Mincemeat much more than a musical comedy

Because underneath all the silliness, songs and deliberately over-the-top characters sits an uncomfortable fact: the entire operation depended on the body of a real person. 

His name was Glyndwr Michael, a Welshman whose body was given the fictional identity of Major William Martin and used to help deceive the Germans. 

A musical like this could very easily risk trivialising the person at the centre of its extraordinary story. Instead, there is a genuine tribute and an acknowledgement of the strange and sad reality behind the operation. 

That gives the show a heart I wasn’t necessarily expecting. 

I simply loved it. The standing ovation at the end felt entirely deserved. I’m already trying to work out when I can see it again. 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos