Premier League cracks down on video

The Premier League said using Vines and Gifs to capture goals and other moments is a breach of copyright

The Premier League said using Vines and Gifs to capture goals and other moments is a breach of copyright

First published in National News © by

Football bosses are launching a crackdown on unofficial clips of action posted on social media.

The Premier League said using Vines and Gifs to capture goals and other moments is a breach of copyright.

During the World Cup, thousands of short videos were posted on sites such as Twitter within minutes of the ball hitting the back of the net.

Now English football's top flight is urging fans not to share the content.

Dan Johnson, director of communications at the Premier League, told BBC Newsbeat: "You can understand that fans see something, they can capture it, they can share it, but ultimately it is against the law.

"It's a breach of copyright and we would discourage fans from doing it. We're developing technologies like Gif crawlers, Vine crawlers, working with Twitter, to look to curtail this kind of activity."

Last year News International - now News UK- struck a deal with the Premier League to offer online highlights to paying subscribers to The Times and the Sun.

A Premier League spokesman said: "The use of Vines and Gifs to show Premier League football is a breach of copyright, and we would encourage fans to use legitimate means to access this content, such as the Sun or The Times goal apps.

"We are working with social media providers to take down pirated clips and hope fans understand the need to maintain the investment model that produces the football they love."

Dean Scoggins, deputy head of sport at the Sun, said the paper is working closely with the Premier League.

He said: "Posting poor-quality videos to social networks is illegal.

"It is breaking copyright laws and although the clips cannot compete with the quality of service that we are providing, we are not happy that it takes place."

Hundreds of thousands of users follow some football Vine accounts on Twitter.

Vine, which is run by Twitter, allows users to capture and share videos that are a few seconds long.

Gif, which stands for Graphics Interchange Format, is used for low-resolution football clips which are then posted online.

Adam Rendle, a copyright law specialist at Taylor Wessing, said any action taken against those in breach would probably depend on the scale of the infringement.

He said: "If it is just you or I on a Saturday afternoon doing it every now and again, I think the tactic there would be to inform Twitter or Vine and get it taken down on an isolated basis.

"If there are serial 'Viners' who are setting up accounts to repeatedly do this every time there is a high-profile match and they have got thousands of followers so it's becoming an unofficial service of goals, they might seek to get the account blocked.

"And if it is starting to get really serious, they might take an offline approach and start issuing proceedings."

The Premier League has faced long-running copyright battles over pubs that use cheaper foreign decoders to screen matches and free online streaming sites.

Mr Rendle said: "I think the problem from this (Vine clips) is anyone who has got a Sky subscription, a phone and a Twitter account could potentially be doing this. That's the real threat.

"The contrary to that is if you can get a relationship with Twitter and Vine to help stamp this out."

Twitter declined to comment but pointed to Vine rules which state that users "may not post content that violates the rights of a third party, including copyright, trademark, privacy, and publicity rights".

The most recent figures show that Twitter received a total of 9,199 copyright "takedown" notices in the first six months of this year - a 38% increase compared with the second half of 2013. Material was removed in 76% of the cases.

A spokesman for one of the most popular football Vine accounts on Twitter said: " The threat of legal action on the uploaders of these Vines we believe to be a scare tactic as the reality of policing this is incredibly difficult.

"The only contact we have had regarding these videos is from press outlets.

"We have had no legal contact of any sort regarding any of our communication. In the event this should happen, we will of course adhere to any instruction or guidance given to us by the relevant authorities.

"At no point whatsoever do we, as a team, upload the Vines ourselves.

"They are sourced from others across the globe who are regularly uploading content to their Vine account. We are merely posting what we can find on the internet that we believe our audience will like. We do this for our love of the beautiful game, not profit."

Comments (5)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

5:03pm Fri 15 Aug 14

notslimjim says...

Quit whining!!

The PL makes millions already.
Quit whining!! The PL makes millions already. notslimjim
  • Score: 2

5:22pm Fri 15 Aug 14

Devils Advocate says...

As always, they took the football away from the people and now it's all about the money. We get the best players in the world, until the world cup starts when they all go home. The family Saturday stopped years ago because poor old Joe Bloggs couldn't afford the prices, and now they are penny pinching over a few seconds on the phone. I wonder what happened to BSB news? Did Murdoch get all of that from the Tories when the furore died down? What a load of selfish chappies they are!
As always, they took the football away from the people and now it's all about the money. We get the best players in the world, until the world cup starts when they all go home. The family Saturday stopped years ago because poor old Joe Bloggs couldn't afford the prices, and now they are penny pinching over a few seconds on the phone. I wonder what happened to BSB news? Did Murdoch get all of that from the Tories when the furore died down? What a load of selfish chappies they are! Devils Advocate
  • Score: 1

8:44pm Fri 15 Aug 14

rggraham1947 says...

Call their bluff; they can't prosecute everybody!
Call their bluff; they can't prosecute everybody! rggraham1947
  • Score: 0

9:59pm Fri 15 Aug 14

TheCaveman says...

Easy solution here - don't go to the match if you can't use your smartphone ! Aren't the leagues making enough money?
Easy solution here - don't go to the match if you can't use your smartphone ! Aren't the leagues making enough money? TheCaveman
  • Score: 1

10:35am Mon 18 Aug 14

RealLivin says...

Football is no longer a sport its business and the idea of private business is profit, I found the recent world cup a complete bore to many brilliant players but very few brilliant teams. It seems the youngsters do well but as soon as they move into the adult professorial game they get tied up in the money side and the football is gone. Its time fans stop winging about it and do something such as stop paying them your hard earned money. If you want sports value for money look else where, it cost me £15 for me and my sons to watch the rugby premier 7's at Mowden Park a few weeks ago, we got front row seats, live on BT sport and I could have a beer while enjoying the games. This is possible due to player wage caps which is not only in rugby but also in french rugby, American football/Hockey, Australian football/rugby and the other thing these all have in common is they are family days, as Devils Advocate states long gone are the football family days. The up coming season cap for the rugby premiership is 4.7 million per club per squad, not per player, offer that to todays footballers and see how many hang up their boots.
Football is no longer a sport its business and the idea of private business is profit, I found the recent world cup a complete bore to many brilliant players but very few brilliant teams. It seems the youngsters do well but as soon as they move into the adult professorial game they get tied up in the money side and the football is gone. Its time fans stop winging about it and do something such as stop paying them your hard earned money. If you want sports value for money look else where, it cost me £15 for me and my sons to watch the rugby premier 7's at Mowden Park a few weeks ago, we got front row seats, live on BT sport and I could have a beer while enjoying the games. This is possible due to player wage caps which is not only in rugby but also in french rugby, American football/Hockey, Australian football/rugby and the other thing these all have in common is they are family days, as Devils Advocate states long gone are the football family days. The up coming season cap for the rugby premiership is 4.7 million per club per squad, not per player, offer that to todays footballers and see how many hang up their boots. RealLivin
  • Score: 0
Post a comment

Remember you are personally responsible for what you post on this site and must abide by our site terms. Do not post anything that is false, abusive or malicious. If you wish to complain, please use the ‘report this post’ link.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree