Miliband under-estimates food costs

Hampshire Chronicle: Labour leader Ed Miliband under-estimated his family's food bill when questioned about the cost of living Labour leader Ed Miliband under-estimated his family's food bill when questioned about the cost of living

Ed Miliband has been accused of being out of touch after under-estimating the cost of his family's weekly food shop.

The Labour leader said the supermarket bill came to around £70 or £80 but later insisted that he was referring only to the amount spent on " basic" groceries such as fruit and vegetables.

Critics were quick to seize on the comments as proof he did not know the details of his household bills and instead "took a punt".

Mr Miliband made the initial estimate after being pressed about his food spending when he was talking about Labour's plans to tackle t he cost-of-living crisis on ITV's Good Morning Britain.

He said: "We probably spend £70, £80 a week on groceries at least, probably more than that. The point is that different families will have different costs that they face but what I am clear about is that there is a crisis facing so many people."

The Labour leader was told on the programme that the average weekly bill for a family of four is more than £100 - so he would be spending "significantly more" than £70 to £80.

"Lots of people are facing a real struggle," he replied. "I am relatively comfortably off, but what I know is that there are deep issues that need to be tackled and we are determined to tackle them."

He later admitted that his shopping estimate may have been on the low side, saying he had been thinking of the bill for "basic groceries".

"Well, I said this morning it was on the basic groceries, the basic fruit and vegetables, about £70 or £80 - the total shopping bill was slightly higher than that, obviously," he told BBC Radio Oxford.

"On the basics, I was saying it was about £70 or £80 but the overall shopping bill would obviously be higher."

Figures from the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) Family Food survey show the average weekly expenditure on all household food and drinks in 2012 was £29.29 per person, an increase of 4.6% on 2011.

Total expenditure on household food and non-alcoholic drink rose by 4.3% to £25.98 per person and was 8.9% higher than in 2009.

Figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) showed the average weekly expenditure for a household with two adults and two children on food and non-alcoholic drinks in 2012 in the UK was £83.60.

The Labour leader's comments sparked robust exchanges on the Mumsnet website, which racked up more than 100 posts on the issue.

TheWordFactory wrote: " Basically, he doesn't know! He took a punt and made himself look daft. I suspect he hasn't stepped a foot in Tesco since 1982."

Contributor bleedingheart wrote: " It is so ridiculous to try and perpetuate this 'man of the people' nonsense.

" Of course politicians need to be aware of the struggles people face and work on the solutions but I don't for a second think Milliband does his own shopping or Cameron for that matter."

LostMyPants wrote: " I'm no fan of Ed, but it could easily be true. Just because you're rich it doesn't mean you have to waste more food."

Shedding wrote: " I think they could easily spend that little in groceries due to eating out of the house so often? Breakfast meeting, lunch on the run, might just appear on the desk, school dinners for the kids, dinner laid on at some kind of event?"

A Tory source said: "It's the same old economic incompetence from the Labour Party that gave Britain the biggest peacetime deficit in history.

"They have no long-term plan to fix the economy and Ed Miliband can't even get the numbers right for his political gimmicks."

Nadine Dorries, Conservative MP for Mid Bedfordshire, said: "If Ed Miliband said his family weekly grocery shop cost £80, he was making it up on the hoof and digging himself a hole - which pretty much speaks for this leadership of the Labour Party."

Priti Patel, Conservative MP for Witham, told The Telegraph: "It sums him up for the hypocrite he is. Out of touch with hard-working Britain."

Comments (7)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

11:59am Tue 20 May 14

bmoc55 says...

And this imbecile aspires to be the next PM!!!!

What a ****
And this imbecile aspires to be the next PM!!!! What a **** bmoc55
  • Score: 5

12:09pm Tue 20 May 14

RealLivin says...

"I think this issue of the cost-of-living crisis is the biggest issue that our country faces and I am determined we tackle it. I am absolutely determined we tackle it."

Well said Mr Millband, does this mean the labour tax hikes on fuel are going to disappear? Financial institutions have many ways to calculate the cost of living but the basic facts are increase fuel and every thing else goes up. Fuel goes up the cost of transport goes up so the cost of goods goes up and you need a pay rise to cover the increase so you can get to work, which we do not get hence the crisis. Its nice to know Mr Miliband has noticed there is a crisis, however this was foreseen and forewarned when labour were last in power and they did nothing to avoid it.
"I think this issue of the cost-of-living crisis is the biggest issue that our country faces and I am determined we tackle it. I am absolutely determined we tackle it." Well said Mr Millband, does this mean the labour tax hikes on fuel are going to disappear? Financial institutions have many ways to calculate the cost of living but the basic facts are increase fuel and every thing else goes up. Fuel goes up the cost of transport goes up so the cost of goods goes up and you need a pay rise to cover the increase so you can get to work, which we do not get hence the crisis. Its nice to know Mr Miliband has noticed there is a crisis, however this was foreseen and forewarned when labour were last in power and they did nothing to avoid it. RealLivin
  • Score: 6

3:44pm Tue 20 May 14

Excluded again says...

Non-story. Asked what his weekly food bill is he said' £70-80 at least. Probably more'.

The it turns out the average bill is £100. Sounds like he spends more or less the average, then.
Non-story. Asked what his weekly food bill is he said' £70-80 at least. Probably more'. The it turns out the average bill is £100. Sounds like he spends more or less the average, then. Excluded again
  • Score: 0

5:26pm Tue 20 May 14

KSO16R says...

The only people who really know how much they spend not their shopping are the people who have the lowest incomes
The only people who really know how much they spend not their shopping are the people who have the lowest incomes KSO16R
  • Score: 4

5:43pm Tue 20 May 14

Dilligaf2010 says...

......"I am relatively comfortably off,"........
......he's having a laugh surely!
Living in a £2.3million (2012 valuation) mansion, only a £400,000 mortgage, with a household income of about £400,000 p.a. , like most politicians, he's lost touch with reality.
......"I am relatively comfortably off,"........ ......he's having a laugh surely! Living in a £2.3million (2012 valuation) mansion, only a £400,000 mortgage, with a household income of about £400,000 p.a. , like most politicians, he's lost touch with reality. Dilligaf2010
  • Score: 9

11:21am Wed 21 May 14

ivegate says...

How many working men would correcly know the cost of the weekly/monthly family food shop?
Mine would not have a clue.
How many working men would correcly know the cost of the weekly/monthly family food shop? Mine would not have a clue. ivegate
  • Score: 5

2:03pm Wed 21 May 14

Withnail Lefty says...

Posh Red Ed, a hypocrite and a liar leading a bunch of hypocites and liars. He's our future Prime Minister don't you know.
Posh Red Ed, a hypocrite and a liar leading a bunch of hypocites and liars. He's our future Prime Minister don't you know. Withnail Lefty
  • Score: -3
Post a comment

Remember you are personally responsible for what you post on this site and must abide by our site terms. Do not post anything that is false, abusive or malicious. If you wish to complain, please use the ‘report this post’ link.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree