Celebrity chef restaurant plans stirs opposition in Winchester

Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall

Abbey Mill: the classical portico

Architects drawing with the classical portico on the left

First published in Winchester Hampshire Chronicle: Photograph of the Author by

OPPOSITION is simmering to plans to convert a historic Winchester mill into a restaurant for celebrity chef and TV presenter Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall.

An invitation-only public meeting was attended by around 50 people who heard how Abbey Mill on Colebrook Street could be converted into a base for River Cottage Canteen and Deli.

Many of the people at the Guildhall were strongly opposed to the plans fearing it will bring noise pollution and traffic congestion on the quiet street.

Katie Warnes, of Colebrook Street, said: “I think it’s fair to say we are all fairly horrified. It would be slap bang in the middle of a residential street.

“We have noise from the car park already but the problem is not one thing in isolation, it’s a combination. Another concern is a fire risk with all the listed buildings around. It’s difficult enough to get down this road as it is but with the extra cars it will be impossible and block off emergency access.

“Nobody wants to see it fall into disrepair and I understand the council needs to maximise its opportunities to make money but it’s not an appropriate location. We don’t feel the council has made enough effort to try and get somebody to take in its current office use.”

One resident, who asked not to be named, said: “There is a moral hazard over the change of use. If you want it as a restaurant then River Cottage is as fine as you can get but guarantee is there it will always be River Cottage?

“We accept there will be problems with living in a town centre but this will exacerbate them and make it a permanent problem.”

Guy Ashton, of Colebrook Street, said: “There are two sensible outcomes here. Either the council decides a restaurant in Colebrook Street is not an appropriate place or they say it is and River Cottage is a great tenant but there are a number of controls.

“There need to be controls over things like the number of deliveries and customers, the times of deliveries, opening hours, outdoor seating, smells, rubbish and noise.”

But there is local support for the plan. John Holder, who runs Wolvesey View bed and breakfast in Colebrook Place, said: “I think it is excellent. It will be a wonderful asset for Winchester. I some extent I have a motive as I run a B and B.

“I think Winchester is showing the way of how to get out of the horrible economic mess. For people to be trying to stop this is incredible.

“I am in favour but they will have to do something about traffic. Perhaps they could treat Colebrook Street like College Street with a barrier to stop through traffic.”

A planning application for a change of use will be made “imminently” by the city council, said a spokeswoman. She explained only 50-60 local people were invited “to get people to understand what the planning process is.” River Cottage has signed a lease to take over the building.

Among the noticeable changes will be the creation of outdoor eating under the classical portico of Abbey Mill that fronts on to Abbey Gardens.

Abbey Mill has history as an eaterie. In World War Two it was British Restaurant where servicemen were able to go for meals. More recently it was home to the city council engineers department. It has been empty for several years and needs extensive building work before it can be let.

River Cottage was asked for comment; a spokeswoman said: "The building is owned by the Council and is going through the planning process currently and so this will be managed accordingly by the Council."

Last month when the Chronicle revealed the lease agreement, Rob Love, River Cottage managing director, in a statement said: “River Cottage is pleased to have agreed terms with Winchester City Council on Abbey Mill, subject to planning and licensing approvals.

“Our first priority is to create a dialogue with residents and the local community to share our ambitions and intentions, and we look forward to meeting with them soon."

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:56pm Thu 29 Nov 12

mabel1966 says...

It would be great to have something in this space that has been empty since I can remember and I am 45 years of age!!!!!!!!
Let him have it.
Surely the residents realise that people will park in town and will walk across to Abbey Gardens. They will not park in Colebrook Street? Surely they have resident parking there anyway?
Living in Water Lane you should see what the parking is like there on a Sunday during the Christmas build up or on Bonfire night when the bonfire is around River Park. If i dont have my car in place by 4pm and i pay for resident parking you will not get parked at all !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bring it on it will be great and not because i will use it because i probably wont but to make use of the wasted space
It would be great to have something in this space that has been empty since I can remember and I am 45 years of age!!!!!!!! Let him have it. Surely the residents realise that people will park in town and will walk across to Abbey Gardens. They will not park in Colebrook Street? Surely they have resident parking there anyway? Living in Water Lane you should see what the parking is like there on a Sunday during the Christmas build up or on Bonfire night when the bonfire is around River Park. If i dont have my car in place by 4pm and i pay for resident parking you will not get parked at all !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Bring it on it will be great and not because i will use it because i probably wont but to make use of the wasted space mabel1966
  • Score: 0

7:37pm Sun 2 Dec 12

wheresthemoneygone says...

Rich Posh Hugh and another poncey restaurant yipee!
Rich Posh Hugh and another poncey restaurant yipee! wheresthemoneygone
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree