Winchester residents demand rethink on Barton Farm development

Permission was granted to build on Barton Farm last year after more than a decade of planning battles

Permission was granted to build on Barton Farm last year after more than a decade of planning battles

First published in News Hampshire Chronicle: Photograph of the Author by

MORE than 100 people have signed a letter to the Hampshire Chronicle demanding a thorough rethink of the Barton Farm development.

Although the scheme for 2,000 homes on farmland to the north of the city has outline planning permission, the signatories argue there is still time to influence important details.

The unprecedented letter says current plans for Barton Farm are flawed and that Cala Homes needs to be persuaded to build a development that is better integrated with the rest of the city.

Signatories include retired architect Kate Macintosh, Rupert Cook, director of Architecture plb, former city councillors Jock Macdonald, Judith Martin, Karen Barratt and John Higgins, Hyde 900 founder Edward Fennell, transport consultant Mike Slinn and environmental campaigner Chris Gillham – along with local councillors, architects, writers, scientists, artists and business people.

One signatory, city councillor Robert Hutchison, said: “People recognise Barton Farm is going to be built, but there is widespread public concern that it is not going to be as good as it might be. The time to think about the overall quality and design is now.”

He added: “The 110 or so names are the tip of an iceberg. We could have got hundreds more.”

The city council is about to set up a Barton Farm Development Forum to help Cala Homes prepare its detailed plans expected later this year.

In addition a meeting has been arranged for next Wednesday, January 16, between members of the 2020 Group - a joint initiative of Winchester Action on Climate Change (WinACC) and the City of Winchester Trust – and Cala to discuss next steps.

Transport campaigner Mike Slinn contends current plans do not provide a satisfactory route for cyclists and pedestrians between Barton Farm and the city centre. The plan involves diverting traffic from Andover Road through the development and Mr Slinn predicts this will cause conflict and greater risk of injury for residents.

He says residents will be deterred from walking and cycling and encouraged to travel by car, worsening congestion and pollution.

Cala originally planned to keep Andover Road but amended the scheme to divert the road into the new estate after public consultation.

Changing the Andover Road diversion is highly unlikely as it is part of the outline planning permission and altering it would involve another planning application.

Mike Emett, Cala land director, said: “The road is one of the matters that has been fixed. The city council is full-square behind proposals for diverting traffic through on a new road. It would require a new planning application. That is not on our agenda.

“We are aware the road issue has given rise to discussion and strong views for and against,” he added.

“We welcome dialogue and are happy to hear what people have to say. We are pleased attention is turning to detail rather than the principle.

“I pretty much agree with what is in the letter. Cala also want to produce a fantastic development that everyone can be proud of, we want to produce something for the community, the city, everyone, so we can say ‘what a fantastic developer Cala is.’ We do not want to miss this opportunity.”

Cala has also organised a public consultation for the Guildhall on Thursday, January 31, from midday to 7pm.

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

9:40pm Thu 10 Jan 13

ascapola says...

A weekday is not ideal for a public consultation. Why not hold it on a Saturday, when more people have a chance to attend?
A weekday is not ideal for a public consultation. Why not hold it on a Saturday, when more people have a chance to attend? ascapola
  • Score: 0

4:32pm Fri 11 Jan 13

Smith1186 says...

Isn't it ridiculous how a beautiful piece of unaltered countryside such as Barton Farm is set for redevelopment as a perfectly good brownfield site littered with abandoned buildings and burnt out cars is on the verge of protection?

Barton farm should be replaced with Bushfield camp, an altogether better site with better access and enough space to provide Winchester with enough housing for years to come.
Why people are protecting a brownfield site over greenfield is unbelievable. Wake up people, before it is too late.
Isn't it ridiculous how a beautiful piece of unaltered countryside such as Barton Farm is set for redevelopment as a perfectly good brownfield site littered with abandoned buildings and burnt out cars is on the verge of protection? Barton farm should be replaced with Bushfield camp, an altogether better site with better access and enough space to provide Winchester with enough housing for years to come. Why people are protecting a brownfield site over greenfield is unbelievable. Wake up people, before it is too late. Smith1186
  • Score: 0

7:04pm Fri 11 Jan 13

homes4people says...

The sooner this devastated piece of countryside is redeveloped the better in my opinion. Taking back the land from intensive farming and creating a sustainable development will help restore its wildlife and biodiversity through development it sounds strange and counter productive but if the development is designed well it can really make a difference. I wish people stop believing the hyperbole from the save Barton farm group.
The sooner this devastated piece of countryside is redeveloped the better in my opinion. Taking back the land from intensive farming and creating a sustainable development will help restore its wildlife and biodiversity through development it sounds strange and counter productive but if the development is designed well it can really make a difference. I wish people stop believing the hyperbole from the save Barton farm group. homes4people
  • Score: 0

12:28pm Wed 16 Jan 13

Yves1977 says...

Smith1186 wrote:
Isn't it ridiculous how a beautiful piece of unaltered countryside such as Barton Farm is set for redevelopment as a perfectly good brownfield site littered with abandoned buildings and burnt out cars is on the verge of protection?

Barton farm should be replaced with Bushfield camp, an altogether better site with better access and enough space to provide Winchester with enough housing for years to come.
Why people are protecting a brownfield site over greenfield is unbelievable. Wake up people, before it is too late.
Barton Farm beautiful? yeah right - chemical drenched and dull, dull, dull, dahling. But is is tucked away where only the people of Weeke and Harestock (in their houses built on farmland in the 50s, 60s and 70s), can see it.
Bushfield Camp is much more sensitive and being on the top of a hill would be seen for miles. The MoD building sshould be demolished and the land returned to open downland.
[quote][p][bold]Smith1186[/bold] wrote: Isn't it ridiculous how a beautiful piece of unaltered countryside such as Barton Farm is set for redevelopment as a perfectly good brownfield site littered with abandoned buildings and burnt out cars is on the verge of protection? Barton farm should be replaced with Bushfield camp, an altogether better site with better access and enough space to provide Winchester with enough housing for years to come. Why people are protecting a brownfield site over greenfield is unbelievable. Wake up people, before it is too late.[/p][/quote]Barton Farm beautiful? yeah right - chemical drenched and dull, dull, dull, dahling. But is is tucked away where only the people of Weeke and Harestock (in their houses built on farmland in the 50s, 60s and 70s), can see it. Bushfield Camp is much more sensitive and being on the top of a hill would be seen for miles. The MoD building sshould be demolished and the land returned to open downland. Yves1977
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree